The $50 Noise-Reducing Pickleball Ball That Has One Cape Cod Town in an Uproar

A Cape Cod town is now requiring players to use a specific noise-reducing pickleball ball that costs $50 each. Players say it bounces like a sponge and puts them at a serious disadvantage everywhere else they play.

The noise-reducing pickleball ball debate just got very real in Mashpee, Massachusetts, and what's happening there might concern every player who uses a public court.

The town's select board received 16 complaints about pickleball noise.

That was enough for local officials to post a new rule directly on the courts requiring players to use a specific 3D-printed ball from a company called Net X, which runs about $50 per ball.

This story, covered by CBS Boston, is a preview of what could roll out at courts near you.

Here is everything you need to know about the rule, why players are furious, and what the noise fight means for the future of public pickleball.

Love pickleball? Then you'll love our free newsletter. We send the latest news, tips, and highlights for free each week.

What Is Actually Happening in Mashpee?

The town of Mashpee on Cape Cod already made efforts to reduce noise at its public pickleball courts.

They installed noise-dampening tarps along the sides and planted vegetation as a sound buffer.

None of that was enough for neighbors who kept filing complaints.

After 16 formal complaints reached the select board, officials decided the ball itself was the problem.

The new rule requires every player to use the Net X 3D-printed low-noise ball.

Originally set to take effect immediately, the town extended the start date to August 13th and said they expect to expand the list of approved balls within a week.

So What's Wrong With the New Ball?

A lot. Local player Paul Key tested the noise-reducing pickleball ball on camera and the difference was immediately obvious.

The Net X ball bounces irregularly, like a sponge rather than a firm pickleball. Players have to swing significantly harder just to generate normal shot pace.

Noise Complaints Close CA Town’s New $1.5M Pickleball Courts

Despite numerous efforts to alleviate the problem — designated hours, encouraging quieter equipment, onsite signage, etc. — the courts are closed for good, effective immediately.

The Dink PickleballAlex E. Weaver

Here is a quick breakdown of the problems players identified on court:

• Cost: Standard pickleballs run a few dollars each. The Net X noise-reducing pickleball ball costs $50 per ball, making it significantly more expensive.
• Inconsistent bounce: The ball does not respond the way any trained player expects. It compresses and releases unpredictably.
• More effort required: Players must hit the ball roughly twice as hard to get similar results, which changes shot mechanics completely.
• Not tournament-legal: No sanctioned event uses this ball. Playing with it regularly could actively hurt your game when you leave Mashpee.
• Visitor problem: Summer tourists who rent courts for a week have no reasonable way to source a $50 ball before showing up.

Player Jackie Ferguson, who tested the ball with friends, said visitors simply are not going to have these balls, and they won't have the means to get them if they're only in town for a week.

That is a real access problem.

You cannot reasonably ask a casual player visiting on vacation to locate and purchase a specialty 3D-printed noise-reducing pickleball ball before stepping on a public court.

Does the New Ball Actually Solve the Noise Problem?

This is the question nobody at the town meeting seemed to fully answer.

One resident speaking at a public meeting pointed out that changing the ball did nothing to change court hours or any other aspect of how the space is managed.

The core complaint from neighbors is not just about the sharp ping of the ball.

It's about the overall noise generated by active courts, including player conversation, movement, and general activity.

Swapping in a quiet pickleball ball addresses one frequency of sound.

It does not move the courts further from homes, reduce playing hours, or limit the number of players using the space at once.

If you want to understand how noise fights like this escalate, take a look at the ongoing turf war between tennis and pickleball, which has been brewing across the country for years now.

Mashpee is not an isolated case. This same fight is playing out in neighborhoods from California to New York.

Noise Complaints Close CA Town’s New $1.5M Pickleball Courts

Despite numerous efforts to alleviate the problem — designated hours, encouraging quieter equipment, onsite signage, etc. — the courts are closed for good, effective immediately.

The Dink PickleballAlex E. Weaver

Why Does This Matter to You Personally?

If you play on public courts, this situation should make you pay attention to your local politics.

Sixteen complaints were enough to force a rule change on an entire community of players. That is not a large number.

If your neighbors near a public court decide to organize, they hold real power over how and whether you play there.

The pickleball community has a reputation problem in some areas, and it is directly tied to noise.

You can read about some of that community friction in stories like this pickleball dispute in a San Francisco neighborhood that took a genuinely unexpected turn.

Being a good court citizen matters now more than ever. If your court is near homes, here are practical steps you can take right now:

1. Watch your volume between points. The ball sound is one thing, but constant shouting and celebration carries further than you think.
2. Know your court's hours and respect them without pushing boundaries on either end of the day.
3. Talk to your neighbors before they file complaints. A conversation beats a town meeting every time.
4. Support infrastructure requests like sound barriers and vegetation buffers at town meetings before noise becomes a crisis.
5. Choose softer balls for early morning or late evening play voluntarily, before a rule forces your hand.

How to Make Friends Through Pickleball: A Beginner’s Guide

If you want to know how to make friends through pickleball, start at the kitchen line, not the parking lot. This guide breaks down exactly how the sport turns strangers into your weekly crew, from your first open play session to a standing Tuesday night group.

The Dink PickleballThe Dink Media Team

What Happens to Your Game If You're Forced to Use a Low-Noise Ball?

This is the practical concern that players like Paul Key raised, and it is completely valid.

Pickleball technique is built around the specific physics of a standard USAPA-approved ball.

The way you reset, the way you drop, the pace you generate, all of it is calibrated to how a real pickleball behaves.

If you want to sharpen those skills, check out these tips that fix your dink, drop, and reset.

A spongy, inconsistent ball breaks that calibration. You start compensating with extra swing speed and altered contact angles.

Then you show up at an open play session or a tournament with a standard ball, and your muscle memory is working against you.

Think about shot selection principles like the low forehand and high backhand rule.

Those decisions are made in a fraction of a second, based on how you expect the ball to arrive.

A ball that bounces like a sponge rewires those expectations in the wrong direction.

Regular use of a non-standard ball can genuinely hurt your performance in competitive play. That is not an exaggeration. It is physics.

How to Hit a Dink Shot in Pickleball: Soft Hands, Low Arc

Knowing how to hit a dink shot in pickleball is the single fastest way to move from recreational player to someone opponents actually fear at the net. This guide breaks down grip, arc, stance, and placement so your dinking game stops being a liability and starts winning you rallies.

The Dink PickleballThe Dink Media Team

What Are the Real Alternatives to a $50 Ball?

Towns dealing with noise complaints have more options than forcing players to use an expensive specialty product.

Several approaches have shown real results without destroying the quality of play.

Here is what actually works in communities that have managed this well:

• Court placement: Designing new courts with natural or structural buffers between play areas and residential zones before noise becomes an issue.
• Restricted hours: Limiting early morning and late evening play is a much more targeted solution than changing the ball entirely.
• Dedicated indoor facilities: Communities investing in dedicated pickleball courts create environments where noise is contained by design.
• Sound panels and fencing: Properly installed acoustic fencing absorbs far more noise than tarps and works at the frequency pickleball actually produces.
• Approved ball lists with affordable options: Mashpee has said it plans to expand its approved ball list. If quieter standard balls like the Franklin X-40 or quieter foam options make that list, the access problem gets much easier to solve.

The good news is that Mashpee's extension to August 13th and the promise of an expanded approved list suggests the town is at least listening to feedback.

That is something.

Noise Complaints Close CA Town’s New $1.5M Pickleball Courts

Despite numerous efforts to alleviate the problem — designated hours, encouraging quieter equipment, onsite signage, etc. — the courts are closed for good, effective immediately.

The Dink PickleballAlex E. Weaver

What Should You Watch for at Your Local Courts?

The pickleball noise issue is not going away as the sport keeps growing.

More courts mean more neighbors affected, and more complaints eventually mean more rules.

Your best protection is engagement. Show up to town meetings when courts are on the agenda.

Know your local officials and understand how noise ordinances work in your municipality.

The players who stay informed are the ones who keep their courts.

You should also stay current on how equipment standards are evolving at the national level.

USA Pickleball's equipment standards are shaped partly by conversations like the one happening in Mashpee right now.

If towns start mandating specific balls and those mandates spread, it will eventually pressure national governing bodies to certify quieter balls for general play.

That could change the sport at every level.

Watch this space. And in the meantime, be a good neighbor at the courts you already play on.

That is the simplest and most effective way to keep pickleball accessible for everyone.

The love of the game is worth protecting, and protecting it starts with the community around the court, not just the players on it.

For a broader look at how communities are reacting to pickleball growth, stories like this one about a net bandit in New York and pickleball landing in Judge Steve Harvey's courtroom show just how far community tensions can escalate when the sport is not managed carefully.

The Mashpee situation is a reminder that the fight for court access is just as important as what happens on the court itself.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a noise-reducing pickleball ball?

A noise-reducing pickleball ball is a specialty ball designed to produce less sound on impact than a standard hard plastic pickleball. The Net X ball required in Mashpee is 3D-printed and costs approximately $50 each. It is not approved for sanctioned tournament play and bounces significantly differently than a standard ball.

Why does pickleball make so much noise?

Standard pickleballs are hard plastic and produce a sharp, high-pitched ping when struck by a paddle. That sound frequency carries easily across distances, especially in open outdoor environments near residential areas. The combination of multiple balls in play, multiple courts, and the elevated frequency is what generates complaints from neighbors.

Can a town legally require a specific ball for public courts?

Yes. Public courts are operated by municipalities, and local governments can set rules for how those facilities are used as a condition of access. Mashpee's select board has the authority to post court rules just as they would for any other public recreation facility.

Players who disagree can speak at town meetings or work with local advocates to push back.

Will using a quieter or foam ball hurt my pickleball game?

It can, especially if that ball bounces inconsistently or requires a significantly different swing to generate pace. Your timing, reset mechanics, and shot selection are all calibrated to standard ball behavior. Regular practice with a non-standard ball can build habits that work against you when you return to standard play.

What should pickleball players do if their courts face noise complaints?

Engage with local officials early, before rules are imposed. Support voluntary measures like restricted hours during early morning and late evening, and advocate for proper acoustic infrastructure like sound panels and dense vegetation buffers. Showing up to town meetings as an organized, reasonable group is far more effective than responding after a rule has already been posted on the court.